While we are not baking cookies every day of the week now, we are happily preparing fresh cookies for you to enjoy in the safety and comfort of your home!
We are offering our favorite hearty cookies here, available FRESH or FROZEN. For frozen cookies, simply allow to thaw overnight at room temperature, or pop in the oven/microwave for a couple seconds to warm up. Enjoy with a cup of tea alongside your favorite book, crumbled up over ice cream, or as a prize (or form of bribery!) for young children. We promise, there is no judgement in how you enjoy!
SEE BELOW FOR FLAVOR DESCRIPTIONS
PEANUT BUTTER FULLY LOADED
Giant peanut butter cookie jam-packed with roasted peanuts, pretzels, coconut, dark chocolate, topped with flaky Maldon salt. CONTAINS: Peanuts, Coconut
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
Classic, All-American favorite. The Good Batch Chocolate Chip cookie is made with a blend of white and brown sugars, a hint of espresso, and high quality dark Belgian chocolate chips.
Soft, chewy vanilla malt cookie loaded with rainbow sprinkles. Popular with adults and kids alike.
TAHINI CHOCOLATE CHUNK (VEGAN + GLUTEN-FREE)
We are so incredibly proud of this magically vegan and gluten-free flavor for it’s rich, salty/sweet flavor and rugged, crunchy-on-the-outside and soft-on-the-inside texture. It was just named as one of the best cookies in New York City by TimeOutNY, and our customers at the bakery and around the city agree. CONTAINS: Almond Flour, Tahini (Sesame)
Anna developed this cookie a couple years back as an option for the Oatmeal Raisin lovers of the world. This cookie is a step-up, or a more sophisticated version, if you will. Oatmeal, currants, pistachios and dark chocolate, topped with flaky salt. CONTAINS: Pistachios
THE BITTERSWEET (GLUTEN-FREE)
Intensely chocolate, intensely rich. A dark chocolate cookie loaded with toasted hazelnuts. Recommended for a mature chocolate-loving palatte only! CONTAINS: Hazelnuts
BROOKLYN BROWNIE (GLUTEN-FREE)
The perfect brownie, right in the middle of fudgey and cakiey. Overtly delicious, secretly gluten-free. We especially enjoy it toasted with ice cream. CONTAINS: Rice Flour
CARAMEL SWIRL BROWNIE
A fan-favorite at the bakery. A rich, dense fudgey brownie topped with a caramel cream cheese swirl.
COCONUT MACAROON SANDWICH COOKIE (GLUTEN-FREE)
A staple of The Good Batch. Buttery coconut macaroons sandwiched together with a milk chocolate caramel filling. CONTAINS: Almond Flour, Coconut
Inspired by the Notorious B.I.G., who grew up just around the block from our bakery, this chewy cookie is loaded with big chunks of housemade buttercrunch caramel candy.
MUESLI JAM BAR
A hearty breakfast or snack bar. A whole wheat crumb base is topped with raspberry jam, a buttery oat crumb and sunflower and pumpkin seeds. High in iron and flavor. CONTAINS: Sunflower Seeds, Pumpkin Seeds
CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER (VEGAN)
This little cookie packs a big flavor. Natural peanut butter, roasted peanuts, applesauce, and raw sugar are the secret ingredients that make this crunchy-on-the-outside and soft-on-the-inside cookie so delicious. Enjoyed by all cookie lovers (including vegans!) CONTAINS: Peanuts
BROWN BUTTER SALTY
Brown butter shortbread cookie made with raw sugar. A signature cookie of our bakery.
OAT CHOCOLATE CHUNK
Hearty oat cookie loaded with milk and dark chocolate chunks, topped with sea salt. One of the first cookies we ever developed.
Made with fresh ginger juice, raw sugar, and high quality molasses, this soft-baked cookie warms the soul year-round.
TRAIL MIX COOKIE (VEGAn)
Part of our signature cookie line, this Oatmeal Raisin cookie is also loaded with sunflower seeds and flaky coconut. CONTAINS: Sunflower Seeds, Coconut
Starts at $0.00
Steven Smith Tea
The Good Batch proudly carries Steven Smith Teamaker, for its incredibly high quality and clean, classic flavors. This will become a staple in your pantry.$10.00
We don’t mind saying that we are obsessed with our granola. It’s a regular breakfast amongst our staff and community alike, and we wouldn’t want$9.00
COOKIE DOUGH to Bake at Home
The Good Batch cookies freshly baked in the comfort of your home! Hooray! Bake for yourself, bake for your roommates, bake for your children andStarts at $0.00
Counter Culture Coffee Beans
The Good Batch is so incredibly proud to call Counter Culture our coffee roasting partners. We have been brewing their coffee and selling their beans$16.00