Enjoy our Baked Goods at Home
Uncategorized
-
Apple Crumble Pie
Apple Crumble Pie for Thanksgiving Dessert made with New York State apples
$32.00 -
Apple Pumpkin Cake
Spiced Apple Cake topped with creamy pumpkin frosting
$36.00 -
Ginger Cookie Pumpkin Pie
Traditional Thanksgiving pumpkin pie topped with a Ginger Molasses cookie crumble
$32.00 -
Pumpkin Chai Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches
Pumpkin Chai Mini Ice Cream Sandwiches for Thanksgiving Dessert
$24.00 -
Apple Bourbon Layer Cake
Spiced Brown Butter Apple Cake layered with caramel and bourbon buttercream for Thanksgiving Dessert
$45.00 -
Pumpkin Loaf (vegan)
Pumpkin Loaf spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger, and topped with toasted pumpkin seeds
$16.00 -
Sweet Potato Meringue Cake
Spiced Sweet Potato Cake layered with cinnamon cream cheese frosting and topped with toasted meringue
Starts at $37.00 -
Seasonal Cookie Assortment
A tasty assortment of seasonal cookies for Thanksgiving dessert
$20.00
Cookies
-
Deluxe Sweet Sampler
A collection of our best-selling treats from Signature Cookies to our popular Sweet & Spicy Nut mix.
$36.00 -
Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
A festively decadent chocolate chocolate chip cookie laced with peppermint
$20.00 -
Signature Cookie Sampler
One Dozen of our classic Signature Cookies.
$24.00 -
Stroopwafel
Our stroopwafel honors the traditional Dutch cookie with a slight twist.
$24.00 -
Ginger Molasses Cookie
Featured in Haagen-Dazs's Artisan Collection, our Ginger Molasses cookie is soft, chewy, and loaded with fresh ginger.
$20.00 -
“Anna’s Favorites” Sweet Bundle
A collection of our favorite baked bars, Signature cookies and gourmet sandwich cookies.
$76.00 -
Brown Butter Salty Cookie
A brown butter shortbread cookie made with raw sugar and topped with sea salt.
$20.00 -
Oat Chocolate Chunk Cookie
An oat cookie loaded with milk and dark chocolate chunks, topped with sea salt.
$20.00
Cakes
Cakes are available for in-store pickup only.
-
Signature Cupcakes
Classic Chocolate and Vanilla cupcakes with a sweet and simple topping.
$33.00 -
Specialty Cupcakes
Enjoy any of our Specialty Cakes as a cupcake!
$38.00 -
Build your own Birthday Layer Cake
Chocolate 0r vanilla cake, chocolate fudge or vanilla bean buttercream
Starts at $32.00 -
Brown Butter Salty Layer Cake
Vanilla cake, caramel, brown butter buttercream, cookie crumble
Starts at $37.00 -
Cookies, Cookies + Cream Layer Cake
Chocolate cake, vanilla and chocolate cookie buttercream, chocolate ganache and chocolate chip cookies
Starts at $37.00 -
Vanilla Hazelnut Layer Cake
White velvet cake, a swirl of Nutella and vanilla buttercreams, candied hazelnut
Starts at $37.00 -
Chocolate Midnight Layer Cake
Chocolate cake, layers of dark chocolate ganache, fudge buttercream, cocoa nibs
Starts at $37.00 -
Chocolate Caramel Layer Cake
Chocolate cake, caramel buttercream, chocolate ganache
Starts at $37.00
Merch
-
The Good Batch Mug
Enjoy your coffee with style. Our teal ceramic diner mug makes for a beautiful sip. We use these mugs at the bakery, and now you can
$7.00 -
The Good Batch Pint Glass
Our glass pint glasses are the perfect vehicle for cookie dipping! We use these glasses at the bakery, and now you can enjoy them at
$5.00
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice Cream Sandwiches are available for in-Store Pickup Only
-
The Crispy Ice Cream Sandwich
Caramel rice crispy treat cookies, Blue Marble vanilla ice cream
Starts at $42.00 -
Ice Cream Sandwich Sampler
Goodwich, The Crispy, Birthday Cake, Mint Brownie Magic
$84.00 -
Goodwich Ice Cream Sandwich
Oat Chocolate Chunk cookies, sea salt, drizzled fudge, vanilla ice cream
Starts at $42.00
