Cakes

Cakes are available for in-store pickup only.

Please note that due to the high volume of Thanksgiving orders this week, our cake pre-order service is temporarily suspended. If you are in need of a cake, please call the bakery to check on available inventory. 718-622-400

Thank you and Happy Holidays!

Fireside Ice Cream Cake
Layers of brown butter cake, ice cream, caramel and cookie crumbs. The ice cream cake of your dreams.
$24.00
Cookies, Cookies + Cream Layer Cake
Chocolate cake, vanilla and chocolate cookie buttercream, chocolate ganache and chocolate chip cookies
Starts at $42.00
Brown Butter Salty Layer Cake
Vanilla cake, caramel, brown butter buttercream, cookie crumble
Starts at $42.00
Chocolate Midnight Layer Cake
Chocolate cake, layers of dark chocolate ganache, fudge buttercream, cocoa nibs
Starts at $42.00
Build your own Birthday Layer Cake
Chocolate 0r vanilla cake, chocolate fudge or vanilla bean buttercream
Starts at $37.00
Signature Cupcakes
Classic Chocolate and Vanilla cupcakes with a sweet and simple topping.
$33.00
Specialty Cupcakes
Enjoy any of our Specialty Cakes as a cupcake!
$42.00