BROOKLYN’S BEST ICE CREAM SANDWICHES
Home of the largest selection of ice cream sandwiches in Brooklyn. Everything is made with:
Locally-sourced ingredients
Fresh-baked cookies
Seasonal flavors
Love!
Our current lineup
Oat chocolate chunk cookies with vanilla ice cream, chocolate ganache, and Maldon sea salt.
Confetti sugar cookies with vanilla ice cream, lemon buttercream, and rainbow sprinkles.
Creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chewy, homemade caramel rice crispy treat cookies
Coconut and almond flour cookies with vanilla ice cream, strawberry curd, and strawberry cake crumbles.
Our seasonal offerings | Call or visit us to see when they’ll be back!
Condensed milk + rice crisp cereal cookies w/ vanilla ice cream, black sesame seeds, and mango curd. Playdate Collaboration w/ Woldy Reyes (@woldykusina)
Double chocolate cookie w/ chocolate ice cream, chocolate cake crumbles, and butterscotch buttercream
Tahini + almond macaron cookies w/ coffee ice cream, coffee caramel buttercream, and crushed espresso beans
Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies w/ peanut butter ice cream, chocolate ganache, and candied pretzel crumbles
brown butter shortbread cookies w/ vanilla ice cream, spicy passionfruit margarita curd, white chocolate dip, and tajin. Collab w/ Fany Gerson (@fanygerson)
Chocolate cookie w/ mint ice cream, mint buttercream, dark chocolate dip, and nonpareils
Chewy brownie cookies w/ vanilla ice cream, caramel buttercream, and homemade honeycomb candy
Pumpkin ice cream sandwiches between two chewy chocolatey homemade cocoa rice crispy treat cookies.
You’ve found the best Ice Cream Sandwiches in New York City! We started the cookie trend 15 years ago in our Clinton Hill, Brooklyn bakery specializing in high-end cookies made from fresh and local ingredients. But how did we create our ice cream sandwiches? During a particularly hot NYC summer day, we did what many New Yorkers do and grabbed some ice cream. The lightbulb went off and we said to ourselves, “Why don’t we make this ourselves and sandwich it between our cookies?” Fast forward to today and they are one of our top selling items! You can check out our lineup of ice cream sandwiches below, but for the newest and most innovative flavors, pop by our Fulton Street bakery. We’re always offering new and unique flavors that we keep secret from the web so dessert fans can discover them themselves.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Our most popular ice cream sandwich is our confetti sandwich, which features vanilla ice cream, rolled in rainbow sprinkles, sandwiched between two sugar cookie confetti cookies.
-
Yes we do! you can find most of our flavors readily available seven days a week in our Brooklyn bakery.
-
Not all Ice cream sandwiches feature real ice cream. However, all of ours do! To be labeled an ice cream sandwich in the United States, the ice cream must have at least 10% milk fat. All Good Batch ice cream sandwiches are made with fresh and local ingredients and are actual ice cream sandwiches, no matter who reads it!
-
The most popular ice cream sandwich in the US ia vanilla ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies. We call our version the Goodwich!
-
The key to making a perfect ice cream sandwich is using great ingredients and baking with love. That’s why we use fresh cookies, creamy ice cream, and source the best ingredients for our customers in Brooklyn.
-
The ice cream sandwich was actually invented by street vendors in New York City in the early 1900’s, In 1982, Richard La Motta popularized his “Chipwich” by selling vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies. Today, we are proud to carry on New York City’s amazing ice cream sandwich tradition.
-
In our unbiased opinion, we do :). We’ve been making them for over a decade with our world-famous cookies. All of our ingredients are locally sourced, and many come from the local Fort Greene Farmer’s Market!
-
An ice cream sandwich is a dessert consisting of ice cream “sandwiched” between two cookies.
-
We sell over ten varieties of ice cream sandwiches. Flavors are always changing so check back for updates.
