The Complete Guide to NYC Birthday Cakes
Birthday cake shopping in NYC is trickier then one might imagine. You can be in a shoebox apartment or a large park. You might transport it on the subway or in a cab. And what do you do with the leftovers? No matter which cake you choose, we’re here to help make your NYC birthday celebration perfect.
4 MINUTE READ
When it’s time to celebrate your special someone, you need the best birthday cake NYC has ever seen! Your friend, sibling, significant other, or child’s special day only comes once a year, which means once again, you find yourself asking where to buy birthday cake in NYC. Have no fear! We have answered all your birthday cake questions, including:
How to choose a birthday cake
What to put on a birthday cake
How long birthday cake is good for
Where to find the NYC birthday cake for you
1. I want to choose the perfect cake for my NYC birthday!
With seemingly infinite options, choosing the right cake can be overwhelming! In my opinion, you can’t go wrong with a classic. What are the most popular birthday cake flavors? The birthday cake NYC goes for most often is a vanilla cake with buttercream frosting. This is that classic “birthday cake” flavor we all associate with nostalgic birthday celebrations. This cake is a good crowd-pleaser, with sweet but subtle flavor that will pair well with the birthday meal and satisfy most every taste palate. If you’re feeling bold, other popular birthday cake flavors include vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream, carrot cake, even red velvet cake! If the guest of honor is a chocoholic, it would be a fun surprise to bring a Brooklyn blackout cake as a very NYC birthday cake, and a retro throwback.
2. Got my cake! Now, how do I decorate it?
To make this cake extra-special, you have endless options for what to put on a birthday cake. I’m a big fan of sprinkles! A classic birthday message written in frosting is also a good go-to. You might also go for some buttercream flowers or piping! An absolute must: candles! Per tradition, one candle for every year the guest of honor has lived. For an even bigger impact, food-safe sparklers can be used! These won’t be able to be blown out to make a wish, like a traditional birthday cake’s candles, so keep that in mind if you go for sparklers vs. candles. Cake decorations are where to let your creativity show! Our storefront in Clinton Hill has candles, cards, and more – everything you need to make your NYC birthday cake personal and special!
3. What happens when the party’s over?
After the last guests have gone home, you may have leftover birthday cake. Shocking, but if it happens to you, you can keep enjoying that cake beyond the special day! How long is birthday cake good for? That depends on how it’s stored. You can store frosted birthday cake 3 ways:
On the counter: consume within 2-3 hours
In the refrigerator: 2-5 days
In the freezer: up to 3 months
The freshest cake is the best cake! For optimal flavor and texture, enjoy your leftover birthday cake as soon after baking as possible.
4. I’m ready! Let’s get this cake!
The birthday beckons, and you need to know where to buy birthday cake in NYC. On our website, you can find where to get a birthday cake in NYC same day, and even order birthday cake delivery in NYC - A fast and easy solution when a birthday comes as a surprise… to you, if you know what I mean.
If you have four days to prepare, you can order a birthday cake through our website and choose a birthday message to be written on top of your cake. And if you want something more special and are asking yourself, “Where can i find a good bakery that gives customized cakes for birthdays?,” we have you covered! For something truly special and unique, check our rotating and seasonal specials for a truly one-of-a-kind cakes made from seasonal and local ingredients from the Fort Greene Farmers Market.
And if you want something delicious, different, and really iconic, you’ll love what we’re cooking up here.
