Beyond the Pie: Creative Thanksgiving Desserts To Try

When you think of “Thanksgiving desserts,” obviously, the most popular Thanksgiving dessert is PIE! Most Thanksgiving gatherings conclude with a slice of pie, but what if pie just isn’t your thing? Or, dare I ask, you’re still hungry for more? If everyone else has volunteered to bring a pie to the meal and you’re scratching your head for a dessert to present to the host, have no fear! We’ve cooked up a hearty batch of non-pie Thanksgiving desserts that are crowdpleasing, easy to transport, and sure to delight on any dessert table! Read on for our suggestions for:

4 MINUTE READ

A plate of Thanksgiving desserts from The Good Batch Bakery in Brooklyn
  1. Quick and shareable tray bakes

  2. Traditional and nostalgic puddings and trifles

  3. Fresh Thanksgiving desserts featuring fruits of the season

  4. Fun and interactive desserts for the youngest guests at the feast

  5. Helpful hints for bringing Thanksgiving desserts to the meal

1. Tray Bakes

One-pan bakes are easy to whip up and transport to the Thanksgiving dinner. Cobblers, brownies, and bars can be cut to small or generous portions depending on the size of the crowd, so there’s enough to go around and share.

  • Pecan blondies and pecan bars are a hand-held, easy to serve twist on the traditional pecan pie.

  • Apple dump cake or fruit cobbler come together quickly and go a long way for minimal effort.

  • Pumpkin Bread is easy to serve, and as an added bonus, makes a great breakfast the day after Thanksgiving when you still have guests but have absolutely worn out the desire to cook for them.

2. Puddings and Trifles

A nod to the kitschy mid-century dinner parties, a decadently creamy pudding or festive colorful trifle will be an unexpected and welcome guest at the feast.

  • Bread pudding is a regional American classic, dating back to its popularity in colonial times. It can be as simple or as fancy as you like, using mostly pantry staples you have on hand already!

  • Ambrosia salad, a forgotten favorite, is a unique conversation piece. Use your grandma’s recipe or start your own new tradition - one that everyone will ask for year after year!

  • Take a page out of Rachel Green’s book and bring a Thanksgiving trifle to your Friends-giving! It’s easier than she makes it look, just make sure you follow a recipe!

3. Fruits of the Season

After the heavy Thanksgiving meal, these tart and bright Thanksgiving desserts cleanse the palate and reawaken the senses from the post-turkey nap.

  • Baked apples stuffed with butter and brown sugar - minimal ingredients for a big impact. If you’re hosting, this is easy to throw together last-minute when you have more guests than expected!

  • Poached pears are relatively simple, but have a great wow factor. Substitute grape juice for a booze-free version, and use your favorite spices for a festive cold-weather treat. Bonus: these are easy to make sugar-free, gluten-free, and vegan!

  • Cranberries: the controversial condiment. Some prefer fresh cranberry sauce, others prefer straight out of the can. Me? I’ll take cranberry cheesecake, thank you.

4. Thanksgiving Desserts for Kids at Heart

If your Thanksgiving gathering has a kids’ table, get them in on the fun! Part dessert, part craft project, these are way more fun to make and 1000% more delicious than a construction paper hand turkey:

  • Cookie Turkeys use sandwich cookies, candy corn, and frosting as “glue” to make small turkey statues. Experiment with different cookie shapes, fun-size candies, and licorice to make edible art!

  • Rice krispie pumpkins are a fun interactive treat to make. Pre-made treats can be shaped into balls and candy straws make excellent stems!

  • If your kids table is old enough to be trusted with the blade, get those youths off their phones by challenging them to carve apple turkeys! I pulled off something like this one at Friendsgiving 2017 and people still talk about it every year. I’m serious.

5. Bringing Thanksgiving desserts to your party

A sweet treat to share is always a sweet gesture, so follow these do’s and don’ts to ensure your shared dessert delights without any added stress:

DO bring all utensils needed to serve! A hearty serving spoon for your bread pudding, or a spatula for your pecan bars. Be prepared!

DON’T use the fine crockery for this one if you’re precious about it. In my family, it’s a tradition to break at least one plate every year (sad but true). Baking pans get left behind in holiday excitement, Tupperware lids get shuffled in together with the feast’s stack of dishes. Save yourself the stress by using a disposable tray, or buying a special one to leave behind as a gift for the host!

DO adapt these recipes to suit your dietary needs! Bringing a vegan, gluten-free, or low-sugar dessert for guests (or yourself!) with special dietary requirements makes everyone feel included in the festivities.

DO have fun with it! The holiday should be about togetherness, not stress. As the great Barefoot Contessa says, “store bought is fine!” You can pre-order a Thanksgiving dessert from The Good Batch Bakery and stop worrying about dessert and start worrying about the football game. We have the best desserts in NYC at 936 Fulton Street in Brooklyn, aaaand we are open at 8:00am on Thanksgiving Day for the coffee you need to get through Turkey Day, and, of course, your last-minute pie needs, because there’s nothing wrong with a classic…

Previous
Previous

A Year of Pie | Holiday Pies From Around the World

Next
Next

The Five Most Popular Thanksgiving Pies in NYC