The Five Most Popular Thanksgiving Pies in NYC

What’s seeing us through the early sunsets and cooling temps of November? Dreams of Thanksgiving pies! When considering the best whole pie to bring to Thanksgiving dinner, there’s a lot to consider: tradition, regional alliances, personal taste preferences. With so many options out there, we wondered, what are the five most popular pies for Thanksgiving? We did exhaustive research and uncovered the top five Thanksgiving pies for your festive feast!

4 MINUTE READ

One of the many Thanksgiving Pies at The Good Batch Bakery in Brooklyn

1. Pumpkin pie

Pumpkin pie is as classic as Thanksgiving itself! Sarah Josepha Hale, often called “The Godmother of Thanksgiving,” described the ideal Thanksgiving meal in her 1827 novel Northwood as concluding with a slice of pumpkin pie. Hale didn’t just put pie into the books, but Thanksgiving as well: for 30 years, she campaigned tirelessly to add Thanksgiving to the calendar of national holidays. She wrote letters advocating for Thanksgiving to 5 US Presidents, until Abraham Lincoln finally declared Thanksgiving a national holiday in 1863. Order your Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie from The Good Batch in Brooklyn by Friday, 11/20/26 for pickup between 11/23–11/26, and cross it off your busy holiday to-do list!

2. Sweet potato pie

While pumpkin pie is the most common of Thanksgiving pies in the North, Southerners prefer sweet potato pie! Similar in aesthetic (we love orange food for fall), sweet potatoes are more common than pumpkin in the American South, which makes a difference if you’re looking for a fresh and local option. While both pumpkin pie and sweet potato use the same spices, the natural sweetness of roasted sweet potatoes requires less sugar to be added for flavor, unlike the mild and starchy pumpkin counterpart. For a slice of old-fashioned Southern hospitality on your Thanksgiving table, rustle up a sweet potato pie!

3. Apple pie

The Thanksgiving holiday is uniquely American, much like the thing we always compare American things to: Apple Pie! Apple pie originated in 14th Century Britain, but became a staple in the colonies when brought across the pond in the 1600s. Pumpkin pie is often a given at Thanksgiving, so if you want to bring a dessert that might not already be on the table, pick up an apple pie on your way to the dinner. Apple pie has Thanksgiving in its DNA: utilizing a seasonal harvest just like pumpkin pie, and the same spices as pumpkin and sweet potato pie (sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, you get the idea). For a regional flair, top your apple pie with CHEESE! Across New England and the Midwest, where dairy farms abound, you’d be remiss if you didn’t add a slab of cheddar, Roquefort, gouda, or Gruyère!

4. Cherry pie

Hear me out: if you’re not including cherry with your Thanksgiving pies, you’re missing out! If you’re unconvinced, check the data: according to a survey by Instacart in 2022, consumers across 11 US states bought more cherry pies than any other flavor of pie. Like the apple pie, this one has roots in England: one of the first recorded cherry pies in history was served to Elizabeth I in Tudor England, around the 1550s. Cherries were brought to plant in the Massachusetts colony in the 1620s. Say, what else happened in Massachusetts in the 1620s? The first Thanksgiving dinner! There, I’ve made my case: cherry pie is a Thanksgiving staple! Three hundred years later, canned cherry pie filling hit shelves in American stores, making the cherry pie easy to bake at home, so you really have no excuse, do you?

5. Pecan pie

In this writer’s humble opinion, the pecan pie is the best of all Thanksgiving pies. Pecan pie filling is simple and relatively straightforward: pecan nuts, eggs, butter, and sugar - usually corn syrup. Karo brand syrup popularized the recipe in the 1930s as an excellent use of their product, but occasionally, molasses is used instead to sweeten the deal. Pecan pie is popular across the American South: so much so that the Texas State Legislature declared it the official “State Pie of Texas” in 2013. The straightforward formula of pecan pie opens it up to endless adaptations and variations. Many recipes will add a little boozy splash for a more grown-up treat, or some chocolate because, well, everything’s better with chocolate! And some pecan pie recipes add BOTH: The Good Batch’s Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie! Sweet, rich, and unctuous, this Thanksgiving pie will wow your guests – or make the host write you an especially sincere thank-you note! You’ll forget where you put the electric carving knife in the kitchen cabinets, but you definitely won’t forget this pie… at least, until it’s time to order desserts for your holiday meals!

Other things to know about pies

To save yourself time around the hectic holidays, pies can be prepped and frozen. Pie crust can be frozen in discs ahead of time, ready to be rolled out and baked when it’s time for turkey! If you’re making a custard-based pie, such as a pumpkin pie, you can even roll and bake your pie crust, then freeze it in the baking pan, fill it and finish baking it fresh for your table. Now for the big question: can you freeze pumpkin pie? Yes! Once it’s fully cooled, wrap the pie (or leftover individual slices) tightly in plastic wrap to seal out excess air, then wrap in aluminum foil to protect against freezer burn. Ready to eat? Your pie goes into the fridge overnight to thaw. Once frozen, pumpkin pie is good for a month, to ensure the best flavor. If the holiday snuck up on you and you’re looking to pick up a pie or two last minute, The Good Batch has whole pies available for walk-ins 11/23–11/26. We open at 8am, and recommend coming early! And when Thanksgiving is done, you’ll want to get a start on that Holiday prep. Don’t worry, we’ve already got some ideas cooked up for you!

Previous
Previous

Beyond the Pie: Creative Thanksgiving Desserts To Try

Next
Next

Your Guide to Small Cakes: 6 Inch and Birthday Sizes